The Best Places to Eat in Bayfield, Wisconsin

Bayfield, Wisconsin, is not only known for its stunning views of Lake Superior and the Apostle Islands but also for its vibrant culinary scene. From fresh-caught seafood to farm-to-table creations, this charming lakeside town offers dining experiences that cater to every taste. Here’s a guide to some of the best places to eat in Bayfield, complete with links to their websites for easy planning.

1. Manypenny Bistro

For a casual dining experience with a diverse menu, Manypenny Bistro is a must-visit. This cozy spot serves up everything from fish tacos to hearty burgers and pizzas, making it a perfect stop for families and groups. The laid-back atmosphere and friendly service will make you feel right at home.

Website: Manypenny Bistro

2. The Bayfield Inn

Dine with a view at The Bayfield Inn, where you can enjoy delicious meals while overlooking Lake Superior. Their menu features everything from fresh salads to flatbreads, and the inviting atmosphere is perfect for breakfast or a romantic dinner.

Website: The Bayfield Inn

3. Pier Plaza

Seafood lovers won’t want to miss Pier Plaza. Known for its fresh Lake Superior whitefish and lake trout, this waterfront restaurant offers a relaxed setting with unbeatable views of the lake. It’s a great spot for a casual meal after exploring the town.

Website: Pier Plaza

Outdoor Seating at Portside Inn

4. Old Rittenhouse Inn

For a more upscale dining experience, head to the Landmark Restaurant at the Old Rittenhouse Inn. This historic venue focuses on locally sourced ingredients and offers gourmet breakfasts and elegant dinners. The charming ambiance makes it a perfect choice for special occasions.

Website: Old Rittenhouse Inn

5. Greunke’s First Street Inn

Step back in time at Greunke’s First Street Inn, a historic establishment serving American classics. From sautéed whitefish to blueberry pancakes, this nostalgic eatery offers hearty meals in a cozy setting.

Website: Greunke’s First Street Inn

6. Morty’s Pub

For a laid-back dining option, check out Morty’s Pub. This local favorite is known for its delicious whitefish tacos, juicy burgers, and a great selection of beers. It’s an ideal spot for a casual lunch or dinner.

Website: Morty’s Pub

7. Sgt. Pepperoni’s Pizza

If you’re craving pizza, Sgt. Pepperoni’s has you covered. Known for their thin-crust pies loaded with toppings, this spot is perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.

Website: Sgt. Pepperoni’s Pizza

Bayfield’s culinary scene offers something for everyone, from fresh seafood and gourmet dining to casual comfort food. Whether you’re in town for a day or a week, these restaurants promise delicious meals and memorable experiences.

Ready to indulge? Plan your Bayfield dining adventure today with these fantastic options!